« Michael Vick: Say it ain't so! | Main| I've been tagged: My Top 5 Side 1 Track 1 List »

Yet Another Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Review (SPOILER FREE)

QuickImage   
Category
Bookmark : del.icio.us  Technorati  Digg This  Add To Furl  Add To YahooMyWeb  Add To Reddit  Add To NewsVine 

Update: There are no spoilers in this review. **Rock

OK, I admit it - I am a Harry Potter fan. I further admit to getting caught up in the "Pottermania" leading up to the release of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, this final chapter in the tale of Harry Potter. So, Kelsey and I headed up to Barnes & Noble around 11PM to pick up our copy.

Before I get into the review, a quick note about the release party at B&N. It was packed. I have never, ever seen that many people in that store - including the release of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (book 6). There were easily over 1,000 people at our B&N, all waiting for a copy. I was number 300 in line (reserved copy folks got to go ahead of those who were buying on the spot)so we would up waiting only 1.25 hours for our copy, leaving about 1:15AM.

I read two chapters that night, and decided that I needed to get some sleep so I could be rested when I tackled the rest of the book the next day. I must say that I had not planned on reading it straight-through - but the book was so, fast-past, so engrossing, and so compelling that to do so otherwise would have prevented me from concentrating on anything else at all. I wound up finishing it Saturday evening at around 11:30PM.

This book differs greatly from any of the previous HP novels in a variety of ways. First, this book is much darker than the rest. While Harry's world may be one that is a fantasy, it is a fantasy world rooted with the goods - and bads - of our own universe. There is a palpable sense of fear and dread in this world - and there is no "cut and dry" definition of what constitutes good and evil. The characters in Harry Potter's world (including Harry himself) come complete with all of the human frailties and shortcomings found in us all. Good has a touch of grey, while evil may be redemptive. The only possible exceptions may be Lord Voldemort and Delores Umbridge, who are both sick with delusion and power (oh, and maybe Bellatrix LeStrange, who is just a nutter).

JK Rowling doesn't hold back in this book - and we're no longer a reading a cute kiddie tale either. Evil is everywhere, everyone is suspect, and death is an all-too-common occurance. Be forewarned: beloved characters die here, because, well, war is hell - even in a fantasy world. Sometimes we witness their deaths, and we feel the survivor's pain; othertimes the deaths occur "off camera", and we find out about them when Harry does - and the shock hits us the same. The book brings us to the lowest of lows, builds up the tension until we almost can't stand it anymore, and then delivers a cathartic climax that will literally make you leap for joy. Finally JKR provides us with an epilogue that satisfies your curiosity about the main characters, without telling you everything. What a great way to end.

Overall this is a tight, fast-paced finale to what will go down in history as one of the greatest fantasy epics of all time. I have always said that there are really two types of authors - those whose works require some "effort" or work upon the reader's part to get through them (and sometimes it is worth it, such as in Frank Herbert's Dune), while there are other books that are effortless to read - the Harry Potter novels fall into this latter category. This final book is an effortless read - and the visuals are so complete that it almost feels like you're watching the much-anticipated final movie (scheduled for 2010, from what I have heard) already.

Brilliant book - and I must admit that I am very sad that this will be the last one. Well, I was going to reread it again anyway, to pick up on the things I missed - I guess there's no time like the present...

Rock
**I try to take one day at a time, but sometimes several days attack me at once.

Comments

1 - I love the Dark Materials trilogy. I listened to it on audio. It was awesome. The production had a full cast.

2 - You can see my pictures from the Borders release party at { Link }

We were #30 in line (I got a # at 8 in the morning). Alas, I do not get to see the book until Aug 13...

3 - I've been stuck in a "Harry Potter" type quandary for some time now. I wanted to read the book very much. At the same time, knowing it was the final installment, I didn't want it to end so I put off picking up the book. Carl was kind enough to transport my UK copy to the states and I visited him last week. No more excuses. I finally picked up the book last night. ... a day and a half later and it's over. bummer.

4 - Who decides which books get press (Harry Potter) and which get censored? After all, censorship is becoming America's favorite past-time. The US gov't (and their corporate friends), already detain protesters, ban books like "America Deceived" from Amazon and Wikipedia, shut down Imus and fire 21-year tenured, BYU physics professor Steven Jones because he proved explosives, thermite in particular, took down the WTC buildings. Free Speech forever (especially for books).
Last link (before Google Books caves to pressure and drops the title):
<a href="{ Link } Deceived (Book)</a>

5 - yeah just got this book it suckks ok my opinion is to just watch the movies a patiently wait for them all to come out. Emoticon Emoticon

6 - Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows eBook (PDF)

{ Link }

7 - Thanks for not spilling anything.
I can't wait to read it but haven't had opportunity to go out and get a copy yet.
We did see the latest 'Potter' movie on the weekend, though. It's getting really mixed reviews. Seems to be a love it or hate it thing. Mostly, people are hating it because it gives one no closure. It's setting us up for the next one, for sure. I, personally, loved it, though.

You want a really good series, try Jack Whyte's take on the Arthurian legends. He makes them seem plausible. They're incredibly well researched from a historical perspective, and have strong, well-written, believable characters.
{ Link }


8 - Got it at 1:15am Saturday morning and finished it at 4pm Sunday afternoon.

A great read, full of highs and lows. I actually had tears in my eyes at one point.

I really hope she does the follow up she discussed on the Today show. There are still a few holes I would like to have filled in.


9 - I second Theo's suggestion of the Darkover series. All of MZB's books are very well written! Along the same lines in the fantasy genre (plus another "high tech gone feudal world" like Darkover), there's Anne McCaffrey's Dragonrider series. Also a LONG series (I've lost count - 12, 13 books? Somwhere thereabouts).

10 - Got 2 copies in mail early Saturday morning, but haven't been able to get near them yet.

What the heck is a "hallow"?

11 - Thanks for the suggestions everyone! I will check out some of the series suggested.

One thing: I agree with the Dragonrider suggestion - to a point. The first three books are excellent, it is really hit-or-miss after that.

I can't wait until everyone has read it, so we can talk about it!

Rock

12 - Got 'it' in the mail yesterday morning.
Had to work though, so I only managed to read about 150 pages. Great sofar !
2 suggestions:
- Philip Pullman: His Dark Materials Trilogy (kid-story fairytale for grownups)
- Marion Zimmer Bradley: the Darkover series (lots of books, so it looks like it never ends Emoticon)

13 - @Bob (9) - Well, I could explain what the "Deathly Hallows" is/are, but that would just spoil the surprise, now wouldn't it? Emoticon

Seriously, the name is actually an important plot point - and I know you don't want me spoiling it for you...

Rock

14 - I loved the book. I was elated with it.. but sad that story is over. I am always a little depressed when I complete a book. But the feeling I felt when finishing this book was such a mixture of joy and sadness.

No more Harry Potter Book release parties...

I was reading that they didn't believe another phenominom like Harry Potter would ever occur. The ride is over...

I'm looking for the next series of books to read..

Any recommendations are greatly appreciated. Emoticon

15 - If you havn't already read the Dark Materials trilogy, do so now before the film comes out and obscures your mind's eye!

Meet Rocky

Rocky Oliver
Rocky Oliver
If you see me at a conference, please stop me and say hi!

Calendar

Search

Categories

LotusGeek Tour 2008

DNUG08-2.png

Proudly Employed By

I am the Vice President of Products for TeamStudio

Our Corporate Blog

I am the Vice President of Products for TeamStudio

Thawte Notary

Thawte Web of Trust Notary

LOTUS GEEK gear

Social Networking


Add to Technorati Favorites

View Rocky Oliver's profile on LinkedIn

Rocky  Oliver

LotusGeek Blog Roll

Why display a blog roll when Planet Lotus does it so much better?

Dilbert

Buy my book!

Blog Buttons

Atheist - Unitarian - Humanist

Atheist Symbol

chalice_150.gif

Happy Humanist

Poker Players Alliance

This Site Designed By

YOU! If you would like to see your name and link here, read more about the Skin the Geek contest!